top of page

Disenchantment

Skribentens bild: Karl Johansson
Karl Johansson
för 3 minuter sedan
4 min läsning

The magic surrounding AI is fading away.


In Dan Olson’s ‘The Future is a Dead Mall’, he comes back to Johan Huizinga’s concept of a magic circle. The idea is that when playing there are rules everyone is expected to follow, for example that you don’t pick up the ball with your hands in a game of football. As long as everyone agrees to the game, the rules are functionally real to all the players, but if someone breaks those rules, the “magic circle” is broken, and reality kicks in again. While this concept was proposed to explain how children’s games work, and has since been widely applied to online multiplayer games, it is also an observable phenomenon in the realm of important adult activities too. Consider for instance the discussion surrounding AI. Almost everyone in the media obeys the rules of the AI game, which are to treat it uncritically as a great innovation and to credit the industry’s speculations that it could become sentient, and possibly evil, and to place the burden of proof on sceptics unsure of fantastical claims about large language models instead of on boosters who tend to have actual direct financial interests in people believe their claims.

 

With the news mostly occupied with Jensen Huang’s various cheating scandals, and the American press especially focusing on the allegations that one of Huang’s paramours acted as a spy for China, it is worth taking a step back and reminding ourselves of what is important. What Huang has been doing is not very important, nor is who takes over Nvidia, nor whether Huang knowingly helped Megaspeed avoid export restrictions, nor whether or not China had any influence in convincing Trump to ease controls on GPU’s. What is important is that the dam of bad news has broken the AI industry’s aura of invincibility.; its magic circle

 

Jensen Huang is a great character for the media, he is a self-made man who has run his company for decades, been a strong voice against other AI leaders’ strange assertions that large language models can and possibly will end humanity, is close to president Trump and have accompanied the president on international travels, and has a signature sartorial style in the form of black leather jackets. He’s easy to write about. But he isn’t that important in the grander scheme of things. If you briefly accept my view of AI – that it is nowhere near as generally useful as boosters say, and will never cure cancer or lead to double digit percentage growth in productivity, let alone become conscious – as a premise, then any purported scandal that Huang is compromised by Chinese intelligence becomes a nothingburger. Who cares if the Chinese got their hands on American GPU’s which are primarily used to build loss-making data centres to power chatbots?

 

The much more important story, and fact, is that Nvidia’s share price has declined from almost $240 in early October to $162 as of last Friday’s close. CoreWeave is down, Nebius is down, Iren is down, Anthropic’s valuation is down, Firmus had to cancel its IPO, the list goes on. Investing in AI is no longer a one-way ticket to profits, and given just how many people, funds, and companies had invested both their hopes and dreams, and their cold hard cash in AI through one security or another that has big implications.

 

The mortgage-backed security market started to wobble in the middle of 2007, and it took until September of 2008 for Lehman Brothers to collapse and make the world aware just how big the housing crash was. Not to catastrophise, but similarly we don’t know who has invested what in which amounts yet, and likely won’t see the full ramifications of this downturn in AI for months, perhaps even a year.

 

But now that the magic circle is broken, the exact kind of lies and hype which made bubble will be met with real scepticism. Dario Amodei has been claiming for years that an AI his company will develop any day now will cure cancer; just the other week he baselessly (and really rather ignorantly) claimed that AI will be able to “cure mental illness”, whatever that means. That kind of talk flew when everyone was excited, but now that people have started worrying it won’t. The AI story is not over, but the time when people uncritically believed everything the AI thought leaders said is.




If you liked this post you can read a previous post about AI here or the rest of my writings here. I also have a section for longer reads I call essays here, I particularly recommend my series called The Bird & The Technoking exploring Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, and its political and cultural implications. It'd mean a lot to me if you recommended the blog to a friend or coworker. Come back next Monday for a new post!

Karl Johansson

I've always been interested in politics, economics, and the interplay between. The blog is a place for me to explore different ideas and concepts relating to economics or politics, be that national or international. The goal for the blog is to make you think; to provide new perspectives.


Written by Karl Johansson

Sources:

Cover photo by Helena Jankovičová Kováčová from Pexels, edited by Karl Johansson

Kommentarer


bottom of page